It is a sentiment, no doubt, shared by
many around the world who view Israel as an unwanted step-child
who just would not go away. Of course this time this sentiment
was expressed by the person who for years now had a front row
seat on every press conference given by last few U.S. presidents.
Helen Thomas was a senior White House Press Corp member.
If you thought that this kind of
rhetoric sounds familiar you are correct. The Iranian president,
Mahmaud Ahmadinejad, repeats it every week and on every occasion
no matter how big or small and to anybody who would listen. He
should be proud of himself as he is obviously is reaching a lot
more people then he ever dared to hope for. It just proves how
much can be accomplished if you are disciplined and persistent.
Of course Mr. Ahmadinajad's big goal
is a destruction of the State of Israel or his own version of
"Final Solution". He must be a much smarter man then given
credit for. There was a time, not long ago, when he was
dismissed as a lunatic. I would say he is more crazy like fox,
when he is not busy killing and raping young Iranians seeking
broader social freedoms.
But since the Iranian crackdowns on
protesters of the rigged elections the world has resigned itself to the
fact that his mind can not be changed no matter what they do and
sending a flotilla or any other form of protest to Iran would
be, to put it mildly, crazy. It's like sending protesters to
Tibet, which is under Chinese control, to support the Tibetans.
Who would ever think of doing something as stupid as that when
Israel is right there in the heart of the Middle East and
finding the support for marching on the Jews does not require a
great effort.
As the Gaza flotilla project was born
there were some organizational issues but once the Free Gaza
movement partnered with Turkish Islamic organization the
logistical problems were resolved. So what if a lot of your
compatriots are Islamic radicals some of whom are seeking
martyrdom. The end justifies the means. When Ayatollah Khomeini
came to power in Iran his allies included the liberals, the
communists and many other political denominations. Of course he
killed a lot of them on his way to create an Islamic state but
the relationship was good while it lasted.
The Hamas controlled Al-Aqsa TV
reported on May 30th, a day before the incident, that flotilla
commander said 'We will not allow the Zionists to get near
us and we will use resistance against them". How will they wage
resistance? "They will resist with their fingernails. They are
people who seek Martyrdom for Allah, as much as they want to
reach Gaza, but the Martyrdom is more desirable" noted the
commentator.
Before boarding the ships destined for
Gaza, the Turkish activists were preparing themselves for a
battle by singing and dancing. There were chanting "remember
Khaibar, Khaibar, Oh Jews! Army of Mohammed will return". They
were of course referring to the battle of Khaibar that took
place in the year of 629 around 150 miles outside of Medina
(modern-day Saudi Arabia) when Army of Mohammed attached the
Jews who were barricaded in the fort of Khaibar. The Jews were
conquered and few years later expelled by caliph Umar.
I wonder if the Jewish activists
aboard those ships, including a Holocaust survivor, were dancing
while listening to these songs. Oh well, the mission for them
was probably more important then minor inconvenience of age old
hatred for Yahudis (the Jews). There were representatives of
many other countries on those ships besides the Turkish and Arab
nationals, including members of the Free Gaza movement, European
MPs, politicians of all sorts and even a Nobel laureate. And of
course the Israel friendly media, including always present
representatives from Al-Jazeera, was welcomed with the open
arms.
Unfortunately the Israeli leaders
grossly underestimated the objectives of this particular
flotilla. While it carried tons of goods in its storage tanks it
was the weight of hatred carried by it's passengers that was
palpable. Israelis intercepted many boats before without an
incident and based on that they send out few lightly armed
troops to board the ships. The flotilla's flagship, Mavi
Marmara, sailing under the Turkish flag was more then ready
to greet them with metal bars and knifes and by the time
the Israeli troops landed on board they were fighting for their
lives.

Turkish activists with
metal rods beating up a fallen Israeli soldier
When asked about
her knowledge about any people
on board that might have had links to terrorism,
The Free Gaza movement co-founder Greta Berlin's response was: I'm the wrong person to ask, you need to ask the Turks. Because
the people Israel is accusing of being terrorists, were on the
Turkish ship. We are responsible only for our own passengers".
Reportedly, Mrs. Berlin considers
herself to be an “internationalist” who doesn’t identify herself
as an American and no longer lives in the U.S. As she distanced
herself from the Turkish activists she went on on usual
anti-Israeli tirade, accusing Israel being a real terrorist
as so on. Like I said earlier, the end justifies the means.
Sometimes you make a pact with a devil to get where you need to
go. The Peace Now movement would be nowhere near Gaza without
Turkish participation on that trip.
In light of this incident I have asked
myself a question. What motivates all these people? Is it their
love for the Palestinians in Gaza or is it their hatred for Israelis
who happen to be Jews? After all, there are many other bigger
conflicts in the world that dwarf the Israeli-Palestinian issue
in terms of lives lost and number of displaced people left
without any means for survival. Is it their support for Hamas?
But Hamas is closer in it's ideology to Islamic Republic of Iran and
Taliban then it is to democratic values of the western
countries.
The answer is not difficult to find.
Let's say the blockade of Gaza s lifted and Hamas will feel free
to do what it's charter dictates them to do, which is to become an
Islamic society that adheres to the Sharia Law. Is that what the
good citizens of the world want for Palestinian people, another
religious dictatorship where women and minorities will have
minimal or no rights? As much as I question the judgment of Gaza
activists and millions of their supporters, I do not believe
that, with the exception of Islamic radical members of the group,
that's the future they want for Palestinian people.
Then the answer lies in the latter. The hatred of
Israel. I do not think that most activists are even thinking
about what future holds for Palestinians should the blockade be
lifted because the future they seek is one that does not have
Israel on the map of the Middle East. I think their main
objective is to contribute to the end of State of Israel as we know
it. The existence of the Jewish state is an unacceptable fact of
life for many and any role they can play to ensure it's demise
is worth an effort even if it's misguided.
There is also a sinister side to the
entire event. While the bodies of the dead Turkish activists
were flown back to Turkey and mourned by their families, the
Istanbul based Islamic group named IHH (or Insani Yardim Vakvi),
who is a major sponsor of the of the entire Freedom Flotilla
enterprise, was openly celebrating their success. The fact that
nine people were dead matters very little except of course for
it's publicity value. Those were the martyrs for the cause.
Without those deaths there would be no scandal and therefore no
gain for the activists. "We become famous" was boasting a
smiling member of the group.
IHH was responsible for purchasing
three ships for the flotilla, including the biggest ship Mavi
Marmara, from the company owned by Istanbul city government, as
reported by New York Times. IHH has close ties to Hamas and
apparently receives donations from affluent Turkish
religious merchants who played a major role in bringing to power
the pro-Islamic Justice and Development party and it's leader
the current Turkish prime minister Recep Erdogan. According
to Professor William Backley in his CNN peace on 6/3/10, the
Justice and Development party "emerged from a hardcore
anti-Western and anti-Israeli Islamist tradition that had close
ties to Hamas and Egypt's Muslim Brotherhood".
Mr. Erdogan was convicted in 1998
for inciting a religious hatred. See, in his younger days Mr.
Erdogan was somewhat of a religious zealot. He was arrested for
publicly reading an Islamic poem with following lines: "The
mosques are our barracks, the domes our helmets, the minarets
our bayonets and the faithful our soldiers". In many other
countries few would pay attention to this poem, but in post
Ataturk Turkey this was a big deal. Erdogan was sentenced to 10
months in jail but was freed after just one hour.
After he was elected a prime
minister in 2002, Recep Erdogan disavowed his hard-line Islamic
views and tried to portray himself as pro-Western conservative.
But that was back in 2002. In 2010 Recep Erdogan is a seasoned
politician who consolidated his power internally, has repeatedly
assailed Turkey's most sacred institution, the army, slowly but
surely distanced himself from his Western allies in favor of
other Islamic countries. The founder of modern Turkey, Kemal
Ataturk must be turning in his grave, as this was exactly what
he was guarding Turkey against. Many secular Turks fear that
Erdogan never really changed his radical views but just hid them
until he no longer felt vulnerable.
Just recently Turkey has held a
military exercises with Syria and couple of weeks ago, along
with Brazilian president, Erdogan was seen hugging Mahmoud
Ahmadinejad as he was trying to sell a crappy Iranian nuclear
agreement to the West. He was very upset when that deal was
declined by U.S. and it's allies. Earlier Turkey's prime
minister declined to support President Barack Obama's push for
tough new sanctions against Iran. He said that Turkey has had a
strategic alliance with Iran since the 17th century and wants a
diplomatic solution to end the deadlock.
As reported by CNN, Turkish prime
minister is also trying to avoid the scrutiny of U.S. lawmakers
who recently supported a resolution in the House of
Representatives that branded the World War I era killings of
over a million Armenians by Turkey as genocide. After the
resolution was passed, Turkey temporarily withdrew its ambassador from
Washington. In March of 2010. Mr. Erdogan threatened to expel
thousands of Armenian workers from Turkey as a reprisal. "If
necessary, I may have to tell these 100,000 to go back to their
country because they are not my citizens. I don't have to keep
them in my country". I suppose old habits die hard.
Over the years Turkey has developed
close military and economic ties with Israel. Turkey was always
referred to as Israel's closest ally in the Middle East. As he
traveled to Tehran, Damascus, Riyadh and other neighboring
capitals it's hard to imagine that Erdogan was not asked and
sited for Turkey's relationship with Zionist enemy. He probably
cringed every time Turkey was mentioned as Israel's ally in the
media.
If Recep Erdogan was to succeed in
being a leader of the Islamic world and embark on his goal of
creating the Pan-Islamic alliances he needed a clean break from
his relationship with Israel. The idea of a flotilla could not
have come at the better time. Very little recruiting was needed.
Once the word was out that the flotilla was sailing to Gaza and
confrontation with Jews was a strong possibility, the volunteers
were pouring in. Turkish government knew full well that many of
the so called Islamic peacenics were seeking martyrdom.
Turkish activists
throwing an Israeli soldier overboard
Picture by IDF Spokesperson
The stage was set and all the actors
were in place. There they were, the ships of peace with western
women in traditional Palestinian kefayas, the devote Muslims
crying for the plight of the Gazans, a customary Jew or two, the
concerned European politicians and of course the other side, the
blood thirsty Zionists. All the makings of a good Greek tragedy.
Unfortunately tragedy it turned out
to be. And it was played impeccably to the last tiny detail. The
public burial
ceremonies that attracted thousands of mourners, the interviews
with the activists telling the horrible stories of how the Jews
stared shooting without any provocation, the mandatory protests
with Israeli flag burning ceremonies performed by hysterical
mobs weeping up already outraged population. The young Turkish
mother who took
her one year-old child on this trip and was willing to do it again
was paraded all over the airways and of course the anti-Israeli
media frenzy began almost immediately accusing Israel of crimes
before even knowing the facts. The usual staff just taken a notch
higher.
Then it was the politicians' turn to
step up to the plate. And what better stage then the UN Security
council where the Turkish minister of Foreign Affairs, Ahmed Davutoglu called the Israeli raid "a bloody stain on the history
of humanity". Big words! Speaking of history, I guess the
Armenian genocide perpetrated by his countryman, the fact that
he would vehemently deny, pails in
comparison to Israeli raid on the hate flotilla.
The same Mr. Davutoglu is now hard
at work to start up an international commission to investigate
Israeli action a la the Goldstone report which was a shameful
attempt to put a blame on Israel alone for Gaza incursion during
the operation Cast Lead in 2009. Israel went into Gaza to stop
the thousands of rockets raining on Israeli cites. One of the main
reasons for those commissions is to neuter Israel so it can no
longer defend itself against it's enemies. The tactic is very
effective, in light of all the bad publicity Israel
gets, and is used over and over again.
During his public appearance on
6/5/10 in the city of Konya, prime minister Erdogan added to the
tensions, insisting that Hamas is not a terrorist organization.
"Hamas are resistance fighters who are struggling to defend
their land. They have won an election" Erdogan told the cheering
crowd of supporters. "I do not accept Hamas as a terrorist
organization. I have told this to US officials... and think the
same today".
That kind of rhetoric is no longer
surprising. Just a week ago I watched Mr.
Erdogan's new best friend, Bashar Al-Asad of Syria, look Charlie
Rose of PBS straight in the eye and say that Hezbollah is a
peaceful organization. Few months ago Prime Minister Erdogan won
the inaugural prize of the Rafik Hariri UN-HABITAT Memorial
Award which he has proudly accepted in the ceremony held in
Beirut. I am curious how does Mr. Erdogan reconcile the fact the
his friend, Bashar Asad, had Mr. Hariri killed along with 9
other people back in 2005?
On the other hand Rafik Hariri's own
son Saad, the current prime Minister of Lebanon, went to Syria
just back in May to kiss the ring of his father's killer. I
guess Hezbollah has convinced him that Israel is about to invade
Lebanon any time now. That's why they are collecting the Scud missiles, all
30,000 of them.
As I am writing this article, the
headlines on the Internet are how in light of the Gaza flotilla
incident, Turkey has emerged as a new leader of the Middle East.
So the entire adventure turned out to be a win-win citation for
most of the participants. Turkey has new found leadership role,
the Peace Now emerged as the rock stars of the radical liberal
movement, Turkish Islamic group IHH has become famous and I am
sure that the donations are just pouring in.
Hamas won because it
was officially accepted as a "resistance movement" by arguably
the most powerful Muslim country in the world. The Egyptians
opened up their side of the border with Gaza. They could not be
seen as siding with Israel. And what was the
price? Nine people dead and few injured. The cynic would say
that some of these people were seeking martyrdom anyway.
So everybody won? Not exactly.
Israel lost and the regular Palestinians of Gaza lost. Israeli
leaders need to take deep breath and look around. Using the
tactics of 1980s and 1990s will no longer do. There is a new
world out there and it is getting more hostile towards the
Jewish state. As Daniel Pipes noted the battle field has moved
to TV tubes and blogosphere and while Israel will never win the
popularity contest she needs to adjust to the new
realities.
They need a new game plan that would
allow Israel to survive in the 21st century. Domestic bickering
needs to turn into the unity government that can deal with
existential threats facing the country. Cut off all the weak links.
Time for internal political correctness has come and gone
because the
stakes are too high. The main goal should be the survival of
Israel and not whether you can hold on to a couple of parcels of disputed land.
As for Palestinian people of Gaza,
they lost because no matter what happens with the blockade they
still have to live under Hamas control. Turkey, Iran and other
Hamas benefactors can try to make them smell like a rose but it
is still a terrorist organization that does not show any sign of
change. They will use the citizens of Gaza as sacrificial lambs
without hesitation if it suits them, especially if there is
any progress towards peace. Because if there is one thing
Hamas is really good at it's knowing how to kill any hope for a
peaceful solution.